Water metering not simply a tax grab

There may be reasons to criticize the metering effort in terms of its troubled implementation but not in terms of the principle involved.

Dear Editor:

Last week, you published a letter criticizing our local government for its effort to meter water usage in Summerland and charge people on the basis of their consumption.

There may be good reason to criticize that effort in terms of its  troubled implementation but not in terms of the principle involved.

Apparently,  last week’s correspondent thinks that any revenue collected by government is a tax. Hence, any attempt to put in a more rational pricing scheme for public services — including fee for service where it can be done — is simply another revenue grab.

This argument is woefully simplistic and does great disservice to an important debate.

Where the technology exists to charge me for my particular water consumption habits rather than have my neighbour subsidize me — or vice versa — I see absolutely no argument in support of the current flat fee system.

Indeed, I am surprised our critic did not go on to suggest that we should stop metering electricity consumption as well and simply move to a per capita charge.

The broad debate about levels of taxation generally is far too important to be trivialized by a muddled argument aimed at user fees.

Years ago, the Secretary of the Treasury Board in Ottawa (the federal government department concerned with expenditure management) had a sign over his desk which read, “Any government big enough to give you everything you want is big enough to take everything you’ve got.”

Think about it.

Mark R. Daniels

Summerland

 

Just Posted

UPDATE: Okanagan air quality index poor due to smoke

Index for entire Okanagan Valley rated at 10+, or very high risk, because of wildfire smoke

Penticton RCMP trying to locate a missing man

Sheridan Graham was last seen Aug. 11.

Child dies in boating incident on Kal Lake

A North Vancouver family was boating on Kal Lake when the incident occured

Penticton Tigers runners up at provincials

The Penticton Tigers capped off a stellar season with a silver medal at the BC’s

Clock is ticking on resurgence of First Nation languages

B.C. Indigenous language diversity unique in Canada

A look at B.C. wildfire smoke from space

NASA provides a timelapse of smoke covering B.C. from space

B.C. Wildfires 2018: Province calls for federal aid

More fires have burned in B.C. already this year than did in all of 2017

Kayak in Indian Arm waters off B.C.’s Deep Cove and feast on famous doughnuts

About a half hour drive from Vancouver, Deep Cove is a great kayaking spot for locals and tourists

Child, 4, attacked by cougar near Fernie

The BC Conservation Officer Service said it happened while the family was fishing

Trans Mountain pipeline protesters practise resisting police at Camp Cloud

Last week, a Supreme Court judge granted the City of Burnaby an injunction ordering protesters to remove everything from the site

Gun used in Fredericton killings is legal, man had licence

Police Chief Leanne Fitch said the long gun is commonly available for purchase, and is not a prohibited or restricted weapon

Ontario will sell pot online when legalization comes in the fall

There are further plans to have pot in private retail stores in early 2019

Woman missing after car swept away by mudslide near Cache Creek

A search is now underway for Valerie Morris, who has been missing since the afternoon of August 11.

Smoke and wind doesn’t stop 10th-annual Feast of Fields

Despite destructive winds, stormy weather and heavy smoke the 10th-annual Okanagan Feast… Continue reading

Most Read