COLUMN: The challenge of a boycott intiative

Some Albertans are caling for a boycott of products from B.C.

An Alberta restaurant’s show of support of oil workers quickly became the catalyst for a boycott of British Columbia.

In response to the B.C. government’s proposal to restrict the flow of bitumen through the Trans Mountain pipeline from Alberta to B.C., Asti Trattoria Italiana, a restaurant in Fort McMurray announced it would no longer serve B.C. wines.

In addition, Alberta premier Rachel Notley has said she is suspending talks on sharing Alberta electricity with B.C.

The story of the wine protest quickly gained national attention, and soon Alberta residents were pledging to boycott British Columbia. They would not buy B.C. fruit, wine or other products, and they would not vacation in British Columbia.

It was an extreme response, but proponents said extreme measures are necessary. The pipeline is needed, and the restrictions will hurt the Alberta oil sands.

Besides, boycotts have been effective in the past.

The Montgomery Bus Boycott, in Montgomery, Alabama in 1955 and 1956, resulted in changes to racial discrimination practices on that city’s public transit buses. And the Indian boycott of British goods in the first half of the 20th century was a factor in India’s quest for independence.

Those boycotts worked, but the most recent was more than 60 years ago. Is there a more recent example where a boycott resulted in noticeable, lasting change?

Still, boycotts are often touted as an effective form of protest.

A few months ago, some suggested boycotting the National Football League as a way to show displeasure with players who would not stand for the American national anthem.

There have been calls to avoid an international chain of coffee shops because the owners are in support of same-sex marriages. And there has been a call to stop patronizing an American fast food chain because the owners were opposed to same-sex marriages.

A multinational food and beverage company has been targeted because of its environmental record as well as its record on human rights.

Russian vodka and Russian caviar came under fire before the 2014 Winter Olympics as a way to show disgust with Russia’s human rights policies.

Closer to home, I’ve heard calls to stop patronizing specific local businesses to punish the owners for views on various issues.

Today’s boycotts tend to be short-lived, lasting perhaps a week or two. It’s possible that by the time this column appears in print, the boycott of B.C. will have fizzled into oblivion.

Why don’t today’s boycotts gain more traction?

Part of the reason is that there are calls for moral outrage on a daily basis, with boycotts suggested every few weeks. When such action becomes commonplace, it loses its effectiveness.

More importantly, the Montgomery Bus Boycott and the Indian boycott of British goods addressed significant social injustices.

And in both these cases, the participants were willing to make sacrifices over the long term in order to realize a goal.

India’s quest for independence took years, not days or weeks.

The Montgomery Bus Boycott lasted almost 13 months and during that time, most African-Americans in that city walked long distances to and from work every day. This wasn’t a minor inconvenience; it was a significant hardship.

An Albertan passing on B.C. wines, a coffee drinker switching shops or a fast food customer choosing a different food outlet doesn’t involve the same level of sacrifice.

I can support people taking a stand for something that matters to them, whether I agree or disagree with the cause.

However, if the goal is to bring about change, I wonder if a call for a boycott is the best way to achieve this goal.

John Arendt is the editor of the Summerland Review.

Just Posted

Ongoing dangers caused by flooding

Regional District Okanagan-Similkameen reminds residents of dangers posed by flooding

B.C. Interior flood risk diminishing

Snowmelt receding but rainfall impact remains a concern

Fair promotes sustainability, environmental awareness

Summerland students to hold event on May 27 in Memorial Park

Blast from the past

Ministry of Transportation shows a neat photo from Highway 3 in the South Okanagan-Similkameen

Study looking at declining mule deer population

Southern Interior mule deer project tracking deer movement and health

Vancouver Island girl scores with winning song for BC Summer Games

‘Colours’ is a perfect theme for 2018 BC Summer Games

B.C. pipeline goes ahead despite scrapped Pacific Northwest LNG

NEB approves amendment for $1.4-billion natural gas North Montney Mainline Project

Update: Wildfire northwest of Kamloops jumps from 60 to 800 hectares

Ground crews and aircraft are responding to an estimated 50 hectare wildfire approximately 55 kilometers northwest of Kamloops, near the Deadman Vidette Road.

Feds limit chinook fishery to help killer whale recovery

Chinook is main food source for only 76 southern residents killer whales left

B.C. mom who died just before daughter’s wedding wanted family to be happy: twin

Ann Wittenberg was pulled into the ocean while on a surf board in Tofino last weekend

Courtenay-Alberni MP calls for lifeguards at popular surf spot near Tofino

The Pacific Rim National Park Reserve is defending its decision to cancel the surf guard program.

Harvey Weinstein to surrender in sex misconduct probe: officials

Would be first criminal charge against Weinstein since scores of women came forward

Media are not an arm of the police, Vice lawyer tells Supreme Court hearing

Ben Makuch challenges Ontario Court of Appeal ruling that he must give materials for stories to RCMP

B.C. launches plan to tackle doctor shortage, emergency room congestion

John Horgan aims to set up regional primary care networks in a ‘team-based’ approach

Most Read