COLUMN: Election results don’t always tell the full story

In the coming weeks, British Columbians will decide whether they want a change to the structure of provincial elections.

The choice in the 2018 Referendum on Electoral Reform is whether to continue with the existing first past the post model or to switch to a proportional representation system.

Under the present system, voters choose the local candidate they prefer. The party that wins the most seats forms the government and has the power in the legislature.

Proponents of this system say the existing model works well and does not need to be replaced.

It’s an established system and it results in governments which reflect the wishes of the voters.

But a quick look at some of the recent B.C. election results should show there is a difference between the voters’ choices and the final results.

Consider the most recent provincial election in 2017.

This was one of the tightest elections in B.C. history, with the Liberals receiving 40.36 per cent of the popular vote while the New Democratic Party garnered 40.28 per cent of voter support.

The close race showed itself in the final results as the Liberals won 43 of the 87 seats while the New Democrats finished with 41 seats.

If the election had been a choice of two parties, the results would have been close to what the voters chose.

But the 2017 election was not limited to two choices. There were 18 political parties, as well as independent or unaffiliated candidates.

Some would argue that the results show one of the strengths of the first past the post system, namely weeding out the fringe parties.

Concerns have been raised that under a proportional representation system, extremist voices and fringe parties would have a greater presence than they deserve.

Or, as a friend of mine has described it, proportional representation is “an electoral system for those unable to build mass appeal for their ridiculous ideas.”

But if this is the case, then how does one explain the Green Party’s results?

The Green Party received with just three seats, despite having support of 16.84 per cent of those who cast ballots.

One in six British Columbia voters cast a vote for a Green candidate. This number is significant.

The Green Party received nearly seven times as many votes the combined total received by the Conservatives, Libertarians, the Christian Heritage Party, Your Political Party, Social Credit, Community, Vancouver Island Party, Land Air Water, BC First, Refederation, New Republican, Cascadia, Action, Citizens First, 4BC and all independent and unaffiliated candidates.

Or consider the results of the 1996 provincial election.

Once again, the B.C. Liberals, under Gordon Campbell and the New Democrats, under Glen Clark, had similar levels of support.

The Liberals received 41.82 per cent of the popular vote while the NDP had 39.45 per cent support.

But the New Democrats won a majority, with 39 of the 75 seats, compared with 33 for the Liberals.

Even if the Liberals had teamed up with the two Reform B.C. members and the one Progressive Democratic Alliance member, they still could not have forced the New Democrats’ hand in the legislature.

The strength of the NDP in that provincial election far exceeded the party’s voter support.

Once again, the makeup of the legislature did not reflect the choices made by B.C. voters.

Could a different electoral system work for us here in British Columbia?

More importantly, would it result in governments which reflect more accurately the wishes of B.C. voters?

John Arendt is the editor of the Summerland Review.

To report a typo, email:
news@summerlandreview.com
.



news@summerlandreview.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

Nomination period closes for Summerland Chamber awards

More than 130 submissions received for 81st annual Business and Community Excellence Awards

Death Café returns to Okanagan

Vernon, Kelowna and Summerland events toast touchy subject

Highway 97 rock slide north of Summerland beginning to stabilize

Costs of road work so far estimated at between $300,000 and $350,000

Family Day long weekend expected to be sunny and cool in South Okanagan

Flurries forecasted for the first half of the weekend, followed by bluebird skies and milder temps

More snow on the way for Okanagan-Shuswap

Up to 5 cm of the white stuff could fall across the Okanagan - Shuswap on Friday

VIDEO: Canada’s flag turns 54 today

The maple leaf design by George Stanley made its first appearance Feb. 15, 1965

Expect delays on Highway 1 west of Golden due to vehicle fire

Expect delays while driving Highway 1 between Golden and Revelstoke. Drive BC… Continue reading

Eight cases of measles confirmed in Vancouver outbreak

Coastal Health official say the cases stem from the French-language Ecole Jules Verne Secondary

Semi loses control on Highway 97A in Shuswap

Slippery roads contribute to crash of transport truck carrying tires

Plecas won’t run in next election if B.C. legislature oversight reforms pass

B.C. Speaker and Abbotsford South MLA says he feels ‘great sympathy’ for Jody Wilson-Raybould

Infighting at Kelowna Yacht Club makes it to court

Marc Whittemore, a local lawyer and prominent member of the club, filed a notice of civil claim Feb. 1

Workshop with ‘accent reduction’ training cancelled at UBC

The workshop was cancelled the same day as an email was sent out to international students

Former B.C. premier Gordon Campbell accused of sexual touching

Accuser went to police, interviewed by Britian’s Daily Telegraph

Most Read