COLUMN: A shift in community debates

In a few days, 2017 will be behind.

The new year is a time to look ahead, to make new plans, set goals and make resolutions. But it’s also a time to look back at the year that was. It’s a time to reflect and to take the lessons of the past and apply them to the future.

Over the past year, two news stories in Summerland — the ongoing Banks Crescent development proposal and the proposed regional compost facility — dominated the news coverage and the discussion within the community.

The proposed Banks Crescent development is a 424-unit seniors housing facility, to be built overlooking the lake. At present, the land is used as an orchard, although it is not in the Agricultural Land Reserve.

The proposed regional compost facility, rejected in fall, called for a facility at the Summerland Landfill which would handle compost and organic waste from within the Regional District of Okanagan Similkameen.

These two stories played out in almost exactly the same way.

At first, the developer or proponent of the project presented information about the concept. Then, those living near the proposed development or facility would voice their concerns.

This level of debate and discourse was extremely good. Those on both sides presented fact-based arguments on why they supported or opposed the concepts.

The Banks Crescent developer and supporters spoke about the housing that would be provided, the number of jobs which would be created and the potential economic impact from this development.

Opponents raised numerous questions, including about the stability of the land where the proposed development is to be built. They also mentioned the effects on groundwater and the potential impact on the trout hatchery.

With the compost facility, the proponents spoke about the need for a regional facility, the way the facility would be managed and the potential economic benefits for Summerland.

These were countered with concerns about the odour from the facility, the increased truck traffic along Prairie Valley Road and the possibility of a spill en route to the facility.

The dialogue about these developments were based on facts and strong, well-reasoned arguments.

But then the discourse moved into a different direction.

The focus of the Banks Crescent debate shifted to a focus on a petition organized by opponents of the project. The petition has been updated regularly and today, more than 3,000 people have supported it.

In response, some of those in favour of the development have also attempted to show the amount of support the project would have.

In addition, many homes near the proposed development have signs showing their opposition to the project.

The same thing played out with the debate over the compost facility, as opponents circulated a petition and posted signs showing their disapproval of the concept.

While these petitions and signs may indicate the level of support or opposition for a project, they do not change the facts of the proposals.

The compost facility is no longer under consideration in Summerland, but Banks Crescent is still on the table.

In the days and weeks to come, the community will have an opportunity to speak out about this issue at a public hearing. Municipal council will then vote on whether to allow this proposal to proceed.

This decision and any other development decision in the community should be made after careful consideration of the merits and drawbacks of the proposed facility.

A good idea is a good idea, even if few people are in favour. And a bad idea is still a bad idea, even if it has plenty of public support.

Ideally, good ideas should also receive plenty of public support, but when this does not happen, a decision should be made based on the merits of the proposal, not the number of people in support or opposition.

John Arendt is the editor of the Summerland Review.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Sprott Shaw College's Lunch with Santa, pictured here at Penticton's 2019 Christmas Parade, will be held virtually this year on Dec. 5. (Western News File)
Construction activity in Summerland was busy in September, according to the latest Summerland building permit statistics. (File photo)
Summerland’s September building permits worth close to $8M

Statistics show increase over same month a year earlier

Rebecca Rudnisky, an X-ray technologist at the Summerland Health Centre, explains the operations of the new digital X-ray unit during a tour by members of the Summerland Health Care Auxiliary. (Contributed)
New x-ray machine in Summerland thanks to Health Care Auxiliary

Auxiliary raised over $800,000 to replace old equipment

(Kelowna Capital News)
B.C. Labour Board orders Peachland cannabis company to reinstate laid-off employees

The B.C. Labour Relations Board determined the employees were laid off due to their plan to unionize

Provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry presents modelling of COVID-19 spread in B.C., March 25, 2020. (B.C. government photo)
B.C. sets another COVID-19 record with 203 new cases

up to 1,766 active cases in B.C., two more deaths

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

(Kamloops this Week)
Grandfather accused of using grandchild to make child porn residing in Salmon Arm area

66-year-old’s offences alleged to have taken place in Kamloops

Vernon-Monashee candidate Harwinder Sandhu signs have been tampered with repeatedly leading up to the Oct. 24 election. (Contributed)
More Okanagan election signs vandalized

Vernon-Monashee NDP candidate Hardwinder Sandhu hit hard with repairs

More and more electric cars are on the road, but one Chevy Bolt owner was shocked to see how much his BC Hydro bill skyrocketed once he started charging the vehicle. (Black Press file photo)
Lower Mainland man sees significant spike in BC Hydro bill after buying electrical vehicle

An increase should be expected, but Brian Chwiendacz experienced a 200-plus per cent hike

The Anonymous YVR is an Instagram page that reviews restaurants and other establishments around B.C. based on how well they adhere to COVID-19 rules. (Instagram)
Anonymous Instagram page reviews COVID-19 safety measures at B.C. businesses

There are a number of public health orders various types of establishments must follow to slow virus’s spread

Penticton Fire Department chief Larry Watkinson advises against using fireworks on Halloween this year. (Jenna Cocullo / Black Press Media)
How to not get blown up or catch COVID-19 this Halloween in Penticton

Halloween amid a pandemic will present a handful of unique challenges

A portion of Pelmewash Parkway was closed briefly Wednesday, Oct. 21, 2020, while Lake Country Fire Department and RCMP responded to rescue an eight-month-old puppy stuck on a cliff. (District of Lake Country - Facebook)
Police and firefighters save Lake Country puppy from cliff

A portion of Pelmewash Parkway was closed briefly Wednesday as fire, RCMP responded to rescue mission

Most Read